"With the success Ive had with turnips the last 10 years I cant understand why others who plant them report their deer wont eat them."

I would be one. Tried them for 3 years and deer walked right by them. Maybe it was that they didn't know what they were or whatever but I don't know if I will try them again.

It seems like turnips and radishes are the same concept as both are brassicas. Mine are coming up great and IF we get some more rain will be really grown by season.

I will be interested in your experiment.